QUECREEK, PENNSYLVANIA

About the Quecreek Mine disaster, Ed Saxman writes, "As you recall, the current Quecreek mine used an out-of-date map of the Saxman mine which didn't show all the workings. At the time, it was alleged by the press that the Saxman mine had falsified the maps. A month later, a map marked 'final' was found at the Windber Area Coal Museum, having been donated only months before then by the family of the mine inspector, Clyde Maize, who retired in 1970 and died in 1976.

"When the Quecreek map and Saxman maps were compared, the workings touched—exactly where the breach occurred. Several years later, other copies of the maps were found in the possession of the owner of the coal being mined (as it was being mined under lease), Consol Energy, Inc.

"In 2002, Pennsylvania state officials also seemed to want to blame the Saxman mine for the incident. But the final report of the federal Mine Safety & Health Administration absolved the Saxman mine... (source). Well, thank goodness all survived—not just the nine men trapped for 76 hours, but also the other crew of nine that got out after wading through water-flooded passages for four hours. Also, the global mining industry had a wake-up call about the dangers of old mines, and new map archive procedures and practices have been implemented all over, so some good came of the whole affair."